New Reviews

Thomas Ligotti ‘Teatro Grottesco’ Review

Teatro Grottesco

Written by: James Keen

“He showed them the way into the nightmare, but he could not show them the way out…” – ‘Teatro Grottesco’.

Surely any writer in whatever genre he or she is writing in aspires to develop and hone their own unique literary ‘voice’, their own use of prose and storytelling technique appropriated to not only relate a tale but to do it in such a way that it is almost instantly recognizable to the adroit reader. Authors such as Edgar Allen Poe, Charles Dickens, Cormac McCarthy and Stephen King all share something of a kinship, in that their works are redolent of their signature mode of expression; they’re familiar because they are identifiable in their creative methodology. Thomas Ligotti is such a writer, and unfortunately he appears to be one who has largely ‘slipped through the cracks’ when it comes to wide recognition. His literary ‘voice’ is similarly unique, but his popularity has, it could be argued, been marginalised by his relentlessly grim subject matter, an aspect of his fiction this reviewer will address later.

‘Teatro Grottesco’ is another collection of short fiction and it’s another sublime cornucopia of tales that are typified by a sense of dread and anxiety. The first story here, ‘Purity’ sets the tone for what is to follow, a solemn and unsettling vignette focused on a family that are near constantly moving from house to house due to the nature of the father’s bizarre experiments in rented basements, introducing a theme that echoes throughout many of the stories to follow, that of the cyclical nature of nonsense. “Nothing that drives anybody makes any sense, if you haven’t noticed that by now,” one character notes and it’s this notion that informs many of Ligotti’s characters motivations. ‘The Town Manager’ is centered around a municipality that exists in a state of chaotic flux, where the citizens are beholden to the god-like commands of a mysterious individual guiding them without challenge for fear of immolation or worse. “Change was the very essence of our lives” our narrator informs us. Moving from this disturbingly whimsical story Ligotti delineates a harrowing sequence of other glimpses into his thematically sinister and disquieting literary landscape. ‘The Red Tower’ is chock full of references to a factory that produces “a line of quite morbid, quite wonderfully disgusting novelty goods” that are so repulsively creative they resonate in the mind long after you’ve finishing reading. A group of stories highlight an eccentrically-envisioned town whose inhabitants and story cogency that owe much to that of fever dream logic. ‘Gas Station Carnivals’ is particularly alarming in its effectiveness to disorient and leave the reader with imagery that is quietly horrifying.

If there’s a unifying sensation to be gleaned from nearly all of the tales here, it’s that of mounting dread. Ligotti is not, it appears, interested in shocking the reader, more in drawing you into scenarios that are nightmarishly surreal and profoundly unsettling. His use of language however is, at times, somewhat bloated and overly intricate; indeed there’s a line in the closing tale, ‘Severini’ where our narrator recants the following slightly damning criticism of a particular character, that Ligotti the writer could himself be accused of, “our minds were numbed by all the verbal build-up that had led to this moment of unveiling”. There is a definite tendency on the author’s part to stray into overly verbose and tediously exact diction at times that has the effect of over emphasizing his narrative intent and makes for a wearying reading experience.

Ligotti has often been compared to Lovecraft, not in the sense that the author is utilizing any of the cosmic-horror mythos popularized by the New England born fantasist, but in his creation of his own curiously realized literary universe. If anything this author has much more in common with Poe and Franz Kafka in his prose style and the storytelling manner in which he explores his own ‘pet’ concepts. There’s a marked sense of dislocation in Ligotti’s settings; you never get a sense of exactly what time period we’re dealing with here. There are references to such things as tape recorders, trams and telephones but other than these recognizable aspects of twentieth century technology there is no real ‘marker’ for where and when his stories are set and this adds to the dream-like nature of the fictional output here.

This reviewer would not recommend diving in and reading this collection of the ‘deliriously preposterous’ cover to cover as it’s akin at times to willfully indulging in a somewhat masochistic  compulsion to immerse oneself in imagery and concepts that are nightmarishly executed. There’s a marked lack of humor in the texts that doesn’t help either in assuaging the queasy sensation while reading that you’re on a carnival ride that refuses to stop; and while the initial thrill is certainly   exhilarating there does come a time when you really do need to get off and “get your bearings” as one character remarks in the story ‘My Case For Retributive Action’.

Ligotti is a deviously creative talent and deserves a much wider audience, if only to dispel the horror community’s widely held contention that he is one of the genre’s best kept secrets.

Highly recommended.

Pick it up right here.

Rating: 4.5/5

About The Overseer (1669 Articles)
Author of Say No to Drugs, writer for Blumhouse, Dread Central, Horror Novel Reviews and Addicted to Horror Movies.

3 Comments on Thomas Ligotti ‘Teatro Grottesco’ Review

  1. Fantastic review of a fantastic author/book collection. I noticed near the end of the review (last paragraph) you started writing like Ligotti, lol. ‘Purity’ is to me, the perfect short story; multiple storylines, weirdness beyond any normal thinking but somehow believable – a fat lady dipping raw hotdogs into a jar of mayonnaise and eating them in one bite – where do you come up with stuff like that? It has a dismal ending and you may be right, it is probably too dark for the general public to embrace, but only because it is too close to terrible circumstances and people in the real world.


    • James Keen // June 25, 2013 at 8:39 pm // Reply

      Thank you very much. I think you might be right regarding the last paragraph, but it wasn’t intentional. Boy, is his stuff weirdly hard to shake off after reading, much like a lingering ailment. I understand that Ligotti suffers from some form of chronic anxiety, which explains a lot regarding his narrative proclivities. There are numerous references to the medications his characters indulge in, and diseases, both of the mental and physical variety that I didn’t include in the review because I didn’t think it was pertinent. I agree with you about ‘Purity’ and your assertion about the appeal of his work and why he isn’t perhaps more popular. He writes the kind of fiction that, after reading, you feel the need to down a double scotch and take a deep and cleansing shower.


  2. I enjoyed this review which draws the anthology together in a comprehensive way. Teatro Grottesco is the first book I have read by this writer and my need of (or desire for) reviews and further analyses is for me a sign of its excellence! Because I have not yet read further I’m not sure of Ligotti’s general style: here I was somewhat bemused by the over-exact diction and unnecessary clarification. I actually thought that this was intentional. The narrative voice, so obsessively cautious and so intent on clarity and legibility is interesting given that it is so often implied that the narrators are unreliable, mentally unstable, etc. The general happenings, arson, murder, and manipulation are violent and extreme, yet the inordinately prudent voice ensures that everything somehow remains dull and without significance. The most interesting aspect of these stories (to me) is that despite the most outrageous events, affect remains flat and grey – and somehow this is the actual achievement of the work. Any thoughts on this?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: